Q: Dear Father Turner,
In light of the recent instruction from the Archdiocese of Portland, asking laypeople to refrain from holding hands or raising their hands in the “orans” posture during the Our Father at Mass, I am hoping for some liturgical clarification.
While the General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM) explicitly details the posture for the priest, it does not explicitly mandate a specific physical posture for the laity during this specific prayer. Given that many Catholics view hand-holding or raised hands as expressions of unity or personal prayer, how should we understand a diocese restricting these gestures? Specifically, does liturgical law grant local Ordinaries the authority to regulate the posture of the congregation during the Our Father, and what is the underlying theological or rubrical reason for discouraging these practices among the laity? The current practice in our parish in New Zealand is both and our priest never seems to care which one we practice.
Thank you for your guidance and expertise.
==
A: You are correct that the GIRM does not mandate a specific gesture for the laity during the Lord’s Prayer.
Some commentators have expressed alarm that lay people are pretending to act like priests in such a case. Like you, I think people who raise or join hands do it “as expressions of unity or personal prayer.”
I’m not a canon lawyer, but I believe that a bishop may enact local liturgical legislation that does not conflict with universal law. The archbishop of Portland apparently saw a need specific to his archdiocese.
On the other hand, the liturgical commission of the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of the Philippines expressly permits the laity to perform either gesture https://cbcpnews.net/
Here’s a previous post: https://paulturner.org/
View All Blog Posts | Explore Books | Submit a Blog Question | Share Post via Email
