Q: Thank you again for all of the guidance you give on all matters liturgical.  I appreciate not only your expertise but the kindness and sympathy of your answers. Looking forward to Sunday, February 2, 2025, I have a couple of questions.  1.)  Based on the missal, is the expectation that all masses that day begin with a blessing of candles an procession?  Whereas Palm Sunday gives three different options for the beginning of mass, I see only one option in the missal for the Presentation.2.)  As February is particularly chilly where I live, is it possible for the blessing …

Q: I recently read in a catholic book titled “The Mass” copyrighted in 1925 with an Imprimatur…. and I quote “that a priest must always have with him the altar stone in order to say Mass.  Five things he can never dispense with: namely the altar stone, water, wine, chalice and bread.”    To add context to the quote, it was followed up with stories about World War I, frontline army chaplains as well as about frontier priests on horseback ”  a Priest who has to ride across the plains to far-off missions carries all his needs in the saddle”, …

The OCF gives two dismissals for the end of the funeral Mass: OCF #176 and, in the Cremation Appendix, #437. The rubrics at 437 (“when the committal is delayed or when the body is to be cremated…” raise a number of questions: In other words, there are four possibilities, which dismissal is used when? Thanks, == A: 1. OCF 437 is used only when cremation is involved. It’s in that special section of the OCF. a. If the body is present and is to be cremated before interment, then 437 is indeed used—but not if the body is to be …

Q: One more question. Late at night, I’ll watch random YouTube searches of Masses throughout the country. I was watching the beginning of a morning Mass at a Cathedral with their bishop presiding. For the Penitential Act, he asked for the mercy of the cross etc. paused, then continued with “May almighty God have mercy on us..”. Then the cantor chanted the Kyrie and transitioned without skipping a beat into the chant of the Gloria. I checked another video to make sure it was a fluke. Same thing the previous Sunday. That’s not exactly “right” either is it?== A: Correct. …

Q: Is the Alleluia sung or said with the antiphon in the Liturgy of the Hours throughout the year except Lent, or only in Paschal time. I perused the GILH but seems I missed it. == A: The alleluia is added to the opening versicle throughout the year except during Lent (GILH 41 and other places). During Easter Time, the alleluia is added to all antiphons unless it would clash with the meaning of the antiphon (120). The English translation did not abide by this, so there are some antiphons where saying “alleluia” at the end just isn’t right, but …

Q: Dear Fr. Paul, when brief announcements are given after the Prayer after Communion is concluded, I have seen many instances where the deacon will stand at the ambo to read the announcements. Yet, GIRM 309 seems to preclude announcements from the ambo. What is correct in this regard, and does the answer change if announcements are done prior to the start of the celebration? == A: GIRM 309 indeed does not permit announcements from the ambo. The deacon best makes them from his chair.  I’m always amazed at how widely this number from the GIRM is ignored. The readings, …

Q: We’re trying to finalize our parish Christmas cards this year, but I can’t seem to find an authoritative answer about whether or not the Immaculate Conception is a holy day or not this year being that it’s transferred to Monday, December 9th. I heard that the diocese next door said it wasn’t; a friend of mine in a different diocese said his bishop asked the USCCB and they said yes. I was originally under the impression that the Immaculate Conception follows the same rules as Christmas in this country, but there seems to be some confusion. The legislation I …

Q: The Order of Dedication of a Church and Altar refers to the relic being placed under the altar. Your book, Our Church, Our Altar, says the relic is placed into the altar. (So, under the mensa, not under the altar, in the ground/platform?) How should we read “under” in the ODCA?  Thanks! == A: ODCA II:5c says the reliquary is placed “under the table of the altar,” or, in Latin, sub altaris mensa. So, yes, into the altar, under the mensa—not inside the mensa as in the past, nor in the ground.

Q: Hello, Father. I am continuing to read your book, “Eucharistic Reservation“, with great interest and much enjoyment. A question and a comment. Question: HC, 17, states: “It is first of all for the Priest or Deacon to administer Holy Communion to the faithful who ask for it.” We have a ministry that takes Holy Communion to the sick or homebound. Does HC, 17, however, imply that a person may request to Holy Communion outside of Mass even if he is not sick or homebound? Comment: On p. 74 of your book, ER, it states: “The distribution of communion does …

Q: Our pastor skips the Kyrie at daily Mass. He only says the “I confess.” I asked him why, and he said he just prefers the “I confess.” I pointed out that the Kyrie is supposed to follow the “I confess.” But he still skips it. Any suggestions of what I should do? == A: You’ve done about all you can do. Another idea is to contact the diocesan vicar general or vicar for priests and let him know what is going on. You are correct. After the confiteor and the absolution prayer, the Order of Mass calls for the …